Culturally right or left-wing?


Culturally right or left-wing? 1
Perseus with Medusa’s severed head, by Benvenuto Cellini, Florence.

I was listening to the latest podcast by Bronze Age Pervert (BAP), and it struck me that, despite all sorts of political contortions, he is still relevant. A great deal of focus is placed on what actually constitutes the right or the left, particularly from a cultural perspective. And that’s quite liberating amidst this constant, finger-wagging war of opinions raging online.

Must the conservative movement consist of Puritans from the free churches, where moral control reigns and no one is allowed to deviate from the norm without risking shame and ridicule? This typical American conservatism is excruciatingly boring, intolerant, and, for the most part, lacking in vision.

Or can the right also consist of adventurous fools, eccentric characters, with strange clothes, habits and quirks, and who aren’t always morally correct? With role models such as Alexander the Great, Alcibiades, Robert Guiscard, Napoleon, Friedrich Nietzsche, Neil Ellis and Camille Paglia? And, beyond that, with an ideal of athletic bodies, nudism, male fraternities and grand schemes?

Just as often, I sometimes get the feeling that BAP is merely a so-called psyop, designed to pervert conservative youth and, by the back door, lead them into left-wing culture. He is a libertine with a passion for the law of the strong, yet also an overeducated academic, aesthete and gourmet – not entirely unlike some members of today’s unworldly champagne socialists.

Be that as it may, I find parts of BAP’s worldview interesting, and more relevant than much of what one reads or hears. It partly sums up my own thoughts, particularly this idea of being economically conservative, but not always culturally so. And that one doesn’t necessarily have to buy into the whole package of views.

Politics is often sold as part of a specific culture. The ’68 Left were revolutionaries; they listened to interesting music and wore cool clothes. Much of the Marxist ideology would never have been acceptable to the youth of that era without the accompanying attractive culture.

Perhaps that is why today’s conservatives find it so difficult to establish a counter-culture to the globalist left. They are too boring. Even a once-popular leader like Viktor Orbán eventually loses elections, mainly because he is a dull old man with dull ideas. He saved Hungary from the hardships of mass migration, yes, and many people thank him for that. But even more ordinary leaders from the former Eastern Bloc managed to hold out. Perhaps mass migration is largely a Western phenomenon? And in the end, the people grew tired of Orbán, despite his being eloquent and dynamic in his own field; but preaching about the church, family, law and justice ad absurdum evidently leads to a slow decline.

People need not only security, but also vision, adventure and spectacle. A right-wing policy that does not also embrace these other aspects of human nature is probably doomed to failure.

If I’m going to give voice to my anti-ideological side, I think many would wish that the vast majority were traditional conservatives – calm, devout, and reliable – so that society and all its intricate mechanisms can function well. Duty and virtue also apply in the workplace and create a very strong workforce, which in turn builds a well-functioning country. At the same time, we ourselves want to be nonconformists – wild and free, without church, state, or duties – and live for ourselves and no one else – yet still within a well-oiled and secure society created by others. Perhaps this is conservatism’s unspoken paradox?

Missa inget
Få veckans viktigaste texter samlade i din inkorg varje måndag. Enkelt att avsluta när du vill.